The Jackson City Council needed more than an hour and a half of often heated debate and five votes to give its approval to the 2026 tax rates for the city during a special meeting on Thursday.
The meeting opened with an explanation of the procedures to calculate the rates for the city based on the total calculation provided by the Breathitt County Property Valuation Administrator.
Mayor Laura Thomas explained to the council members that the rates are calculated to “bring in the same amount as last year,” but members immediately began to discuss other possible rates.
Based on the calculations, the “compensating rate” would set the rate per $1,000 of assessed value at .2840.
The special council meeting followed a public hearing about the proposed rates, at which no member of the public made a comment or questioned the calculations.
“When was the last time we lowered it (the tax rate),” councilmember Steve McIntosh asked.
Two members of the council were delayed by lane realignment work on Highway 15 and joined the meeting a few minutes after it started.
McIntosh proposed that the rate be left at .2800 (the 2025 rate) instead of the calculated compensating rate.
“I’m not for raising taxes,” councilmember Tommy Noble told the city’s board. Noble also noted that the compensating rate could be seen as a tax increase by the public.
During the debate, McIntosh said that he was “penalized” by tax increases because of the large amount of property that he owned.
As the debate continued, council members discussed the city finances and the impact that buy-out properties had on tax rates. They mentioned the loss of possible raises for city employees and the impact on the budget for the new council and incoming mayor.
Councilmember Renee Haddix said that she worried that a rate less than the compensating rate would “handcuff the city” and leave the city without “enough funds to adequately run the city.”
“Property owners want a break too,” McIntosh said.
After some discussion about the actual cost differences between .2800 and .2840, the first proposal was made by Debbie Miller and seconded by Steve McIntosh to set the rate at .2800.
A vote led to a deadlock of 3-3, with McIntosh, Debbie Miller, and Kenneth Partick voting yes and Tommy Noble, Renee Haddix, and Jason Hall voting against the proposal.
Mayor Laura Thomas told the council that she was not voting to break the tie.
“I’m not voting on this, and I legally don’t have to,” she said.
“You are the tie-breaker,” Councilperson Noble said, but Thomas refused to cast a deciding vote.
“This is not passed,” she said. “Make another motion or further discuss and come to a consensus. I’m not going to vote and I don’t have to.”
After a lengthy discussion, a motion to approve the compensating rate was rejected in a similar 3-3 vote, with Miller, Patrick, and McIntosh voting no. The mayor again refused to vote to break the tie.
Councilmember Tommy Noble described the difference as a “minuscule” amount and expressed some frustration at the council impasse.
The debate turned to the Mayor’s choice to withhold her vote, and she again explained her reasoning, saying, “I’m a lame duck,” and that she did not “feel compelled to break a tie.”
Noble again moved that the compensating rate be approved “to preserve the best interests of the city.” That motion again fell to a 3-3 tie with the same drawn lines as the previous vote on a similar motion.
Apparently frustrated with the process, Councilmember Jason Hall said, “If we are going to lower it, let’s lower it.” He proposed setting the rate at .1800, which would have reduced the city’s revenue by half, according to Mayor Thomas.
“Think very seriously about this vote,” she said as she called for cooler heads and clearer minds. Despite a second, the motion failed by a 4-2 vote, with only Haddix and McIntosh voting in favor of the reduction.
Councilmember Tommy Noble described the process as “Mickey Mouse stuff,” and he told the council that he said that with “all due respect to Mickey Mouse.”
Steve McIntosh returned to his original motion and moved that the council adopt the current rate of .2800 rather than the compensating rate. The motion, seconded by Debbie Miller, was approved by a 4-2 vote, with Jason Hall changing his vote to create a majority. Haddix and Noble both continued their opposition.
A brief discussion of a proposed sidewalk grant for South Jackson followed, with some council members questioning the costs associated with a sidewalk that “serves no residents.”
Steve McIntosh moved that the project be tabled to look into how the estimated $844,000 in sidewalk funds could better be used in South Jackson.
The special called meeting was adjourned after an hour and forty-one minutes.
Members of the Council will have to give the tax rates a second reading and approval during the regular council meeting in November.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here